GPT-4V image analysis use case…that’s VERY controversial…

Another example of using GPT-4V to perform image analysis. Bonus points for those who figure out what/where this image is depicting (and why that makes the results controversial).

Model output:
“Preliminary Observation:

• The image depicts a large rock face with distinct patterns and layered formations.
• There appear to be horizontal stratifications, indicative of sedimentary layering.
• The base shows significant erosion, which appears more pronounced than at the upper levels.

Determine the Type of Rock:

• The rock face displays horizontal layering, suggesting it may be sedimentary rock.
• The color is primarily beige with some darker striations, but grain size and mineral content cannot be discerned from this image alone.

Classify Erosion Patterns:

• Mechanical/Physical Erosion: There are signs of cracks and some rounded shapes at the base, possibly from freeze-thaw cycles or mechanical abrasion.
• Chemical Erosion: There’s no evident discoloration, pitting, or flaking on the visible surface, making it hard to confirm chemical erosion.
• Biological Erosion: There doesn’t seem to be noticeable erosion caused by biological factors in this image.

Look for Water Patterns:

• The base of the rock face has pronounced erosion, and the patterns suggest possible water flow, perhaps runoff or splash erosion.
• There aren’t clear signs of mineral deposits or streaks that would confirm past water movement.

Check for Wind Indicators:

• The smoother upper surfaces might indicate some wind erosion, but there aren’t signs of a sandblasted appearance or horizontal striations that would confirm this.

Investigate Surrounding Environment:

• The image doesn’t provide context about the surrounding environment, making it challenging to gather information about climate, vegetation, and water sources.

Consider Human Impact:

• There’s no visible evidence of human-induced erosion or disturbances like construction or mining. However, the context outside the image is needed for a more comprehensive assessment.

Document Observations:

• The rock face displays horizontal sedimentary layering.
• Pronounced erosion at the base, suggesting water-related wear.
• Possible signs of mechanical erosion, but chemical and biological factors are inconclusive.
• The environment surrounding the rock face is unknown.

Consult Geological Literature:

• Without specific location details, it’s difficult to refer to geological literature or research papers about this rock face.

Conclusion:

• The primary cause of erosion on this rock face appears to be related to water, given the pronounced erosion at the base.
• Mechanical erosion may be a secondary factor, considering the rounded shapes and cracks observed.
• Chemical, biological, and human impacts are inconclusive based on this image alone. More context or a closer inspection would be necessary for a definitive conclusion.”